A Black Girl’s Guide To The Best Christmas Bars In NYC For A Holly Jolly Christmas

Listen, if you know me then you know I’m not the biggest fan of NYC, but when it comes to holiday magic, there’s really no other place to be. The festive lights, jaw-dropping window displays, and snow-covered trees make the perfect backdrop for an unforgettable holiday season. And if you’re looking to escape into a winter wonderland with friends, and a cocktail in hand, NYC has some of the best Christmas-themed bars around town ready to put any Grinch or Scrooge in a festive mood.

So here’s your Black girl’s guide to the best Christmas bars in NYC, where every sip will give you a reason to celebrate the season. I’ll be back each year to keep this updated and add more festive locations and reviews.

3 Of The Best Bars In NYC (With Christmas-Themed Drinks)

1. Frosty’s Christmas Bar (Midtown East)

• What Makes It Special: Frosty’s Christmas Bar, may just be a pop-up but they take their holiday decor very seriously! With walls covered in lights, ornaments, festive scenes, and naughty elves, it’s the perfect place for a memorable night out with friends.
• Festive Drinks: Don’t miss their signature holiday cocktails like the “Bad Santa” or the “Miracle on 5th Street.” And trust me on this when I say — their spiked hot chocolate is a must!
• Must-See Features: The immersive decorations and photo ops make for endless Instagram opportunities, so be sure to charge your phone.
• Tips: Arrive early to beat the crowds or reserve a table for guaranteed seating.

Full Frosty's review coming soon!

2. The Mean Fiddler (Times Square)

• What Makes It Special: Known for its lively atmosphere, The Mean Fiddler transforms into a festive hotspot during the holidays. The bar is decked out in holiday decor with a party vibe.
• Festive Drinks: Sugar Cookie Shots anyone?? Or indulge in an “Apple Cider Margarita” for a seasonal twist.
• Must-See Features: Their $25 holiday bottomless brunch & dinner is a mighty fine way to party.
• Tips: Perfect for groups looking for a high-energy night out. Try their holiday-inspired food menu as well.

3. Miracle on 9th Street (East Village)

• What Makes It Special: This pop-up Christmas cocktail bar delivers whimsical holiday vibes with creative drinks served in festive mugs. The cozy, intimate setting is perfect for escaping the holiday rush.
• Festive Drinks: The “Snowball Old-Fashioned” and “Jingle Balls Nog” are crowd favorites, and you can even buy the mugs to take home.
• Must-See Features: The playful drink names and cheerful staff add to the festive atmosphere.
• Tips: Lines can get long, so try to visit on a weeknight.

BONUS: Angel of Harlem (Harlem)

• What Makes It Special: While not exclusively a Christmas bar, Angel of Harlem gets into the festive spirit with themed brunches like their “Ugly Christmas Sweater Brunch” and “A Very Grinchmas Party.” The lively atmosphere and vibrant decor make it a fantastic spot to celebrate the holidays.
• Festive Drinks: Their famous rum punch is a crowd-pleaser, alongside holiday-inspired cocktails served during their themed events.
• Must-See Features: They have unlimited brunches and a lively playlist that’ll have you dancing in your seat or the aisles.
• Tips: Make a reservation to secure your spot, especially during their popular brunch events.

Ready to make this holiday season unforgettable? Whether you’re toasting with a holiday cocktail or dancing the night away in your ugliest Christmas sweater, these NYC bars promise to deliver a night full of fun, laughter, and cherished memories. Let the holiday celebrations begin! Don’t forget to share your favorite holiday bar experiences with me in the comments or tag me on Instagram at @adventureswithtequila!